Neurodiversity, suffering and the classroom

What are we really trying to explain?

Dr John Greenall, consultant community paediatrician, explores how Christian professionals can respond thoughtfully and compassionately to the growing recognition of neurodiversity and the varied needs of the children- and families- they work with.

If you’ve been teaching for a while, you may feel that something has changed. More children seem to be struggling, and the complexity of what teachers are managing can feel overwhelming.

 

What should we make of this?

 

The recent Fonagy Review highlights something really interesting. Recorded diagnoses of autism and ADHD have increased (as has psychological distress among young people), while estimates of the underlying prevalence of autism and ADHD have remained relatively stable.

 

Why? Several factors are involved including improved recognition, changing help-seeking behaviour, social pressures and the way services operate.

 

But I’d like to go further in this article, because there's another change I've noticed in my work as a community paediatrician. People increasingly want a diagnosis, but what they expect from it seems to have changed.

And perhaps this also links to seeking diagnosis.

 

I keep tissues on my desk for a reason. Over 20 years in clinic, I've noticed that the tears haven't disappeared when I give a diagnosis, but increasingly they're tears of relief rather than pain or shame.

 

For some, it’s relief that a diagnosis can open doors to support. For others, it can act as a ‘shame-reliever’ - reassurance that their child isn't simply naughty, or that they haven't failed.

 

But I wonder whether we sometimes ask diagnosis to do more than it can. We want to know not just what'shappening, but why. Families may have spent years wondering why school is so difficult, why relationships are hard or why ordinary demands seem overwhelming. Now they have an ‘answer’.

 

“I thought I was going mad.”

“This is why they’ve been struggling.”

 

Of course, autism and ADHD can explain particular patterns of development and difficulty. But autism doesn't automatically explain a child's anxiety, school refusal or relationship difficulties. There may be neurodevelopmental contributors, but bullying, family circumstances, sleep, and the child-environment 'fit' may influence things too.

A diagnosis may be part of the explanation without being the whole story.

“A diagnosis may be part of the explanation without being the whole story.”

 

I imagine this is important in schools. Teachers need to understand children's needs accurately, but one label won't explain everything. And just because a diagnosis doesn't explain every difficulty, that doesn't mean those difficulties aren't real.

 

Perhaps this reflects something wider in our culture. We're often good at looking for causes and finding categories that help us understand our experiences. But explaining howsomething happens doesn't always answer what it means, or how we're to live with it.


We want to know that our struggles don't define us, that we belong, and that suffering doesn't mean we've failed.

 

Christian faith offers a bigger story within which we can make sense of suffering, meaning, identity and more. Every child is made in the image of God, with a dignity that doesn't depend on achievement, independence or ease of behaviour.

 

They – and we - suffer in a world that isn't as it should be, but we can't always explain why a particular person suffers. The book of Job warns us against easy answers, and our Christian faith doesn't promise that we'll understand every difficulty. It does offer a story of creation, brokenness, redemption and hope - a story in which suffering needn't be evidence of personal failure, even when we can't explain it.

 

For teachers, this means taking children's difficulties seriously without expecting a diagnosis to explain everything. Some children need accurate assessment and substantial adjustments; others may need help with anxiety, changes to their environment or a trusted adult. Often, they need several things at once. We can offer support while still encouraging children to learn and grow.

 

A diagnosis can help us understand a child, but it can't tell us the whole story of their life - and it should never become a substitute for knowing them.

 

 

 

https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/independent-review-into-mental-health-conditions-adhd-and-autism-final-report accessed 24 October 2026


Dr John Greenall is a consultant community paediatrician, writer and speaker with a particular interest in neurodevelopment, children's mental health and the wellbeing of families. A Christian and father of four, he is interested in how family life and the wider culture shape the way children and parents flourish. He is the author of ‘Connected Dad’, which explores how fathers can build stronger, more connected relationships with their children.



Next
Next

France’s education crisis: could it happen here?